Panthers suffer tough loss

Manav Malik in action for Endeavour Hills on Saturday. 203007 Picture: GARY SISSONS

By Tyler Lewis and Nick Creely




It was a sense of déjà vu for Dandenong as it fell millimetres from victory in its first encounter after Christmas.

Unfortunately for the Panthers it has been a similar story to many games through this season, and it very well could be the margin between them and finals cricket.

In its match on Saturday against Fitzroy-Doncaster, the Panthers were sent in on a slow green track in overcast conditions.

After losing openers Brett Forsyth (10) caught behind and skipper Tom Donnell (7) to a dubious leg before decision, the Panthers were in need of a rebuild.

Ed Newman and Cam Forsyth slowly but surely resurrected the innings before Newman was victim of the sensational arm of Victorian Premier Cricket champion Peter Dickson.

With a consistent fall of wickets inside the first 15 overs, Forsyth combined with James Nanopoulos to build a competitive total.

When Nanopoulos rocked back and pumped a short ball to the fence only metres off the ground; the games trajectory, as it has seemed all season, was in his hands.

After the slow start, the Panthers had clawed back into the contest through Forsyth (25) and Nanopoulos (30) who pushed the total to 3/89 without risk at the half-way point.

Shortly after the drinks break was the passage of 10 overs that cost the Panthers dearly, losing the set Forsyth and Nanopoulos before the reliable Comrey Edgeworth also found himself in the shed, as Dandenong lost 3 / 4.

A fighting performance with the bat from Jacques Augustin against his old side and Pete Cassidy nudged the Panthers to 144, short of the mark the Panthers would have wanted at drinks, but something for the bowlers to work with.

The Christmas break proved to have no impact on Nanopoulos as he continued on his merry way with the ball, claiming three of the first four wickets to equal the Dandenong Cricket Club record of 313 victims.

The Lions coasted along ticking over the run rate until Pete Cassidy gave his side a sniff, snagging two wickets in one over to inject some life into the Panthers.

Unfortunately for Dandenong, the season of heartbreaking losses continues into the New Year as the Lions hung on to a two-wicket victory – the third defeat of the season by two wickets or less.

Dandenong once again impressed with the ball, but the Panthers” struggles with the bat continued in Victorian Premier Cricket on Saturday. 199128 Picture: STEWART CHAMBERS

Close losses have seemed to be the story of the Panther’s season, skipper Tom Donnell said his side has often been on the good side of the close matches and understands they need to be better if they want to win games in tight moments.

“It is frustrating, there have been a few games we thought could have gone either way,” he said.

“We just haven’t been good enough, or haven’t had luck, we just haven’t been able to win.

“This year it seems we haven’t had our luck but that is the way cricket goes, when games are close you need a bit of luck and we haven’t had that this year but we haven’t played well enough to be honest.

“We just need to improve and play the key moments a bit better.”

At the start of the year, the Panthers’ bowling was heavily doubted after the retirement of club work horse Darren Pattinson, but Dandenong find themselves in unfamiliar territory, struggling for performances with the bat.

“It has been a difficult year we have had as batsmen,” Donnell said.

“The wickets we have played on have caused some uncertainty in the group, not making excuses we need to be better than that.

“We have had a lot of guys that have got starts but not been able to go on, we have left a few runs out there and been in really good positions at times and then threw it away, even on Saturday we weren’t in a bad position.

“I thought batting first was always going to be difficult on that wicket and we were in a decent position at drinks, but we fell over in the 10 overs after drinks and it cost it dearly.

“When we have had a bad patch, it has been an extremely bad patch and in cases it has cost us games, we need to be able to hold teams and get momentum back our way.”

Dandenong will face Ringwood at Shepley Oval this weekend in another one day match.

Down at Mervyn Hughes Oval, Casey-South Melbourne meanwhile suffered an untimely loss to Footscray as it looks to keep pace with the top-eight.

in a 32-per over match reduced off the back of rain the previous day, the Dogs had a bat first after play finally got underway at 1.30pm, and it was spearhead and milestone man Nathan Lambden (2/37) who broke through off the first ball of the game.

Lambden – playing his 100th first XI match at Premier level – removed dangerous opener Dan Sartori, but the Dogs, one of the most potent batting groups in the competition, quickly went on the rebuild through stars Dean Russ and Travis Dean.

Combining rock-solid defense with still a mind firmly fixed on keeping the scoreboard ticking along, the pair added 87 before Jordan Hammond (1/33) managed to snare Dean for 38.

Despite the Swans – largely through the spin of Luke Wells (3/26) – finding regular wickets, the Dogs got itself into a strong position for the win, finishing 7/171 with Russ’ 67 providing plenty of headaches for the visitors.

Needing close to a run-a-ball in the chase, the Swans got off to a bright start through Luke Wells (23) and Nathan Freitag (36), but the required run rate and the strangling effort with the ball provided by Russ (4/24) – who backed up his starring effort with the bat – saw the Swans rolled for 153 with seven balls to spare.

With 11 points seperating the Swans from eighth position, the group will be needing a victory against the struggling Monash Tigers on Saturday to stay in touch with the finals race.



Endeavour Hills battled hard on Saturday, but ultimately fell fighting to Melton at Syd Pargeter Reserve.

Batting first after being sent in, the Eagles scrambled to 170 off 44.3 overs, with keeper batsman Manav Malik (25) top-scoring as the home side struggled to cash in on a series of starts through the middle order.

The home side looked the goods early with the ball to snare a wicket, but the visitors – off the back of an unbeaten 52 to skipper Nathan Taylor and a strong hand from Matthew Stead (40) – found the runs with four wickets and overs still in the bank.

Vinu Mohotty was the pick of the bowlers for the Eagles to snare 2/20 and continue his brilliant season.

Noble Park (8/189) meanwhile picked up a win against Taylors Lakes (187) at Pat Wright Oval, with champ Marasinghe Perera (62) starring for the Parkers.



The struggling Pearcedale faces an uphill battle to avoid another tough loss, this time to Heatherhill at home on Saturday.

The Hills were sent in, and despite the early wicket of the dangerous Steven O’Donnell, belted its way to 5/250 off 65 overs before declaring, with skipper Sam Mullavey smashing his way to a maiden century for the club. Kristian Miller also struck 52 to be a menace for the home side.

With just an hour to survive, the Panthers lost three wickets to be 3/26 and will need to do a lot right to stay in the contest when play resumes on Saturday.

In the remaining matches across the Peninsula Division, Jayde Herrick (5/28) once again dominated for Somerville (3/103), who already have first-innings points against Pines (94), Moorooduc (8/252) had a strong day with the bat against Main Ridge, while Red Hill (2/60) is in the box seat against Long Island (112).


Your first stop before buying a home. View the whole picture.